RAID 5 With Two Failed Drives. What Can Still Come Back.

A RAID 5 survives one failed disk. With two gone it cannot be rebuilt and no software can make up the data that was only on them. What can be done is to read the disks that are left. DRE Pro opens the array partially: the missing parts read as empty and every file is graded by how much of it lies on the disks present. Files wholly on them come back whole; the rest are marked partial, so you know before you save which will open.

What RAID 5 With Two Failed Drives Looks Like In DRE Pro

These are the tools DRE Pro gives you for this job and what each one does. The free download includes the scan and the preview, so you can see what it finds on your own drive before you decide whether a licence is worth buying.

01

Opens From The Disks Left

A RAID 5 with two or more members missing, a RAID 6 with three or more or a RAID 0 with one missing opens from the members present: Linux md, hardware RAID (DDF) or a layout set by hand.

02

Every File Graded

Each file shows how much of its data is on the members found. Wholly present, it is recovered whole; partly present, it is marked Partly On Missing RAID Member.

03

Bring A Disk Back First

If one of the failed disks still reads, even in part, image it and add the image. With one member missing, a RAID 5 is rebuilt from parity.

04

Folders Whose Parent Is Gone

On ext4, as WD My Cloud and many NAS boxes use, folders whose parent lay on a missing member go under Lost Folders and loose files under Lost Files, not dropped.

05

How Much Is Readable

The array's card in the drive list says what share of it can be read from the members present, so you know what to expect before the scan starts. An array missing more disks than its parity covers is listed as Partial and each file in it is later marked whole or partly on a missing member.

06

Deep Scan Over What Is Left

A Deep Scan finds files by their contents in the parts of the array that are present.

Partial And It Says So.

An array with more disks missing than its parity covers is listed as Partial with how much of it is readable and each file in it is marked whole or partly on a missing member.

How It Works, Step By Step

  1. Stop. Do not force the array online, start a rebuild or re-create it. Label each disk with its slot.
  2. Image every disk that still reads, the weakest first, with Create Disk Image.
  3. Open RAID Recovery and add the disks or images. Auto Build RAID reads the layout from Linux md or hardware RAID metadata; without it, set the level, order and chunk size by hand.
  4. Scan the array. Save the files marked whole first, then decide which partial ones are worth having.

Is This The Right Tool? The Short Answer

It is the right tool if your situation is under Use It When and your drive is under Works With. Check Its Limits before you buy. The free download scans the drive and shows the files it finds, so you can see the result before you pay anything.

Use It When

  • Two disks of a RAID 5 failed or a second one failed during the rebuild.
  • A RAID 0 lost one of its disks.
  • Only some of a NAS's disks are left.
  • A RAID 6 lost three disks.

Works With

Levels
RAID 5 with two or more members missing, RAID 6 with three or more and RAID 0 with members missing; at least one member must be present.
Metadata
Linux md (most NAS boxes), DDF from hardware RAID controllers such as Dell PERC and LSI MegaRAID or a layout set by hand.
Members
Disks and images: raw, split, E01, virtual disks and images that a hardware imager saved as numbered chunk files.

Its Limits

  • Data that was only on the missing members cannot be recovered by any software.
  • Large files are rarely whole on a partial array.
  • Partial arrays were tested on a real WD My Cloud disk with ext4. Other file systems are read from whatever of their records lie on the members present.
  • Files in a folder whose parent was on a missing member keep their names, but that folder's own name is lost.
  • RAID recovery, partial arrays included, needs the Enterprise edition.

Why People Pick DRE Pro For This

Not a list of adjectives. These are the three things that change what happens to your files in this kind of recovery. DRE Pro only reads the damaged drive, shows you what it found before you pay and puts a real person on the phone when you are not sure what to do next.

Nothing Passed Off As Whole

Every file is marked by how much of it is here, so nothing reaches you as whole that is not.

Small Files Survive Best

A file smaller than one stripe chunk often lies wholly on one disk, so photos and small documents come back best.

The Disks Are Only Read

Nothing is written to any member, so a specialist can still work on them afterwards.

Updated . Written and checked by the DataRecoverix team.

Why Two Failed Disks Is Different

A RAID 5 spreads its data across the disks in stripes, with one parity block in every stripe. Parity lets the array work out any one missing block, so one failed disk loses nothing. With two disks missing from the same stripe there are two unknowns and one equation: the missing data cannot be worked out, by DRE Pro or any other tool.

That is why the first thing to try is the disks themselves. A disk marked failed often still reads for most of its surface. If one of the two can be imaged, even with gaps, the array is back to one member missing and every stripe that does not cross those gaps is rebuilt from parity. A disk that dropped out long before the second failure holds older data; if you know which one failed first, leave it out.

Do not let the controller or NAS rebuild, repair or re-create an array with two members missing. Each of those writes to the disks and can destroy what is left.

What A Partial Array Gives Back

Each disk of an N-disk RAID 5 holds about one Nth of the data, in chunks commonly of 64 KB to 512 KB. A file smaller than a chunk often lies wholly on one disk; a large file is spread over all of them. So with one disk of three, many small files come back whole and almost no large ones.

In our test on a real disk that was one member of a three-disk WD My Cloud RAID 5, with the other two missing, a Quick Scan listed 300,410 files and 52,644 of them, 695 GB, lay wholly on the disk present. Of 37,058 JPG photos, 21,873 were whole; of 15,822 PDFs, 110 were.

When Only One Disk Is Missing

Then nothing has to be lost. A RAID 5 with one member missing or a RAID 6 with up to two, is rebuilt from parity as it is read and Auto Build RAID can work the layout out with one member missing. The RAID Recovery page covers that case.

Questions People Ask Before This One

Short, honest answers. For anything else, the support desk picks up Monday To Saturday, 11:00 AM To 7:00 PM.

Can A RAID 5 Be Recovered With Two Failed Drives?
Not completely, unless one of the two can be read again. With two members missing, parity cannot rebuild what was on them. DRE Pro recovers the files that lie wholly on the disks left and marks the rest partial. If a failed disk still reads, image it and add the image: with one member missing, the array is rebuilt from parity.
How Much Can I Expect Back?
It depends on the number of disks, the chunk size and the files. Small files often lie wholly on one disk; large files rarely do. With one disk of three, expect many photos and small documents whole and few videos or other large files.
Can A Failed Disk Still Be Used?
Often. A disk marked failed may still read for most of its surface. Make an image of it with Create Disk Image, which keeps a map of what it could not read and add the image as a member. What could not be read from it stays missing. Bad-sector handling is tested on simulated errors; a disk with real bad sectors is still to be tested.
What About A RAID 0 With One Drive Failed?
RAID 0 has no parity, so one missing member is like two missing from a RAID 5. DRE Pro opens it from the disks left and recovers the files wholly on them, each marked whole or partial.
Does It Work On A NAS?
Yes, for Linux md RAID, which WD My Cloud, Synology, QNAP and most other NAS boxes use. Partial arrays were built and tested on a real WD My Cloud disk.
Which Edition Do I Need?
Enterprise. Putting a RAID together, whole or partial and scanning it come with Enterprise, which also covers CCTV, forensic and memory images, cloning, hashing and the write blocker. The free download shows the RAID tools locked, so you can see them before you buy. The Pricing page compares the three editions.

More Software Pages

All Software

What Happened To Yours?

Every Situation

Pick the situation closest to yours. Each page explains what usually happened to the drive, which scan to run, what can and cannot come back and the one mistake to avoid before you start, so the loss does not get worse while you read about it.

Drives This Covers

All Drives

Scan For Free.
Pay Only To Save.

See every file DRE Pro can bring back before you pay anything. Buy a licence only when you want your files saved.